Bug When a Scene first loads it takes 2 presses of a button to make a panel visible

In my LevelScene I have 2 UI buttons, one for reset and one for home. I have 3 panels, 2 for the reset and home confirmation and a win panel. When I load my LevelScene for the first time the buttons take 2 presses of home or reset to open a confirmation panel, but only a single press on all subsequent presses. I thought the onClick() wasn't happening because of something in my input system but when I added logging to my TogglePanel() function it seems to be called on the first click yet my panel still doesn't activate. Here is my code and the debug that results. I pressed each of my buttons 3 times during run time.

Code (CSharp):

1. private void Start()
2.     {
3.      
4.         if (openPanel != null)
5.         {
6.             openPanel.SetActive(true);
7.             openPanel.SetActive(startsVisible);
8.         }
9.     }
10.     public void Toggle()
11.     {
12.         Debug.Log("Toggle Panel");
13.         if (openPanel != null)
14.         {
15.             bool isActive = openPanel.activeSelf;
16.             Debug.Log(openPanel.gameObject.name + " Panel open = " + isActive);
17.             openPanel.SetActive(!isActive);
18.             Debug.Log("Panel open now = " + openPanel.activeInHierarchy);
19.         }
20.     }

Debug Log:

Code (CSharp):

1. Toggle Panel
2. ExitUI Panel open = False
3. Panel open now = True
4. Toggle Panel
5. ExitUI Panel open = False
6. Panel open now = True
7. Toggle Panel
8. ExitUI Panel open = True
9. Panel open now = False
10. Toggle Panel
11. RestartUI Panel open = False
12. Panel open now = True
13. Toggle Panel
14. RestartUI Panel open = False
15. Panel open now = True
16. Toggle Panel
17. RestartUI Panel open = True
18. Panel open now = False

Any advice? This script is attached to each button and openPanel is a public variable and each button only has it's own panel referenced. I'm combing through code but I don't believe the panels are referenced elsewhere (is there a way to trace this for sure?). None of the buttons on the panels themselves (applied from the same prefab) have this issue. I also have a level win panel which gets called from my score manager script and that activates when call it the first and only time in a script. I first thought it may be from the new input system because of my touchscreen multi-tap events but the problem persists even if I disable the simulated touchscreen controls in the input debug, not to mention the function seems to be running. Note, the code o