Smart Merge not working

I am getting an error when I try to use SmartMerge to merge these scenes.

The error returned is 'found unexpected end of stream' for each of my scene files (BASE,LOCAL,REMOTE).

I have attached the scene files. They are from Unity 2017.3.0p3

 

Hi guys. A few months ago, we ran into this problem where the merge tool suddenly started crashing. This was about the time that our only scene file reached about 35 Megs. Today, our scene is much larger, approaching 60 Megs. The windows crash message is "YAMLMerge has quit unexpectedly.".

Is there a command-line param that we can use to expand the amount of RAM that YamlMerge uses or put it into 64bit mode? At the very least, we would like to see which errors that we may have or maybe it's just a size issue.

If we have an error in our scene file, it seems to load just fine into Unity (2017.3.1p3) and we want to have multiple people working in this scene and simply merge the changes like we used to do. Any suggestions would be helpful. If you have the source for the YAML Merge app that you use, we can build it here and try that.

 

@ryanc-unity sorry the scenes have changed since then.

 

I'm using Git with the Unity YAML Merge tool. After the SmartTool processes the files, it opens P4Merge to see what needs to be fixed manually.

When looking at the results of Smart Tool pre merge some values in the $BASE file are missing:

It should show in the middle something like: m_LocalPosition: {x: 125, y: 1, z: 125}

But if I check the $BASE file before it was passed to Unity YAML Merge, the base file contains the correct values for the location of the object:


Is this the expected behaviour?
If so, kind of misleading... =/

 

same here. did you ever find a solution?

 

so, I've tried using the tool to resolve an actual conflict in a scene file... and it didn't actually change the scene. After it was all said & done, the git conflict markers were still littered all through the file.

 

I still really don't understand what the merge tool is supposed to DO. Information is very sparse and the documentation is mysterious. What does argument -p do? I know it says "premerge", as if everyone has heard of this word. I don't know what it means. It implies to me that no actual merge occurs. There aren't even great references to this term - there are some references in Mercurial documentation, but no definition.

HOW does it resolve conflicts? It's supposed to use the files specified, but I don't see any information in there. Am I supposed to populate it with rules before it does anything?

The documentation also alludes to the existence of the settings files but doesn't tell you where they are. As a foolish junior developer it took me several hours of googling for instructions and examples before I realized that I could run the command line option and get usage instructions for the tool. Please put this information in the documentation page. Couldn't hurt to also put all the arguments and their descriptions in there.

I tried to use the tool with a more experienced developer and it didn't seem to do anything. Maybe our case is a fallback case, but we couldn't get the fallback tool to launch. So uh... how on earth does the tool decide which cases are fallback ones? In the case of a fallback, does the tool do anything or do you just have to manually compare the yaml files?

I just would like MUCH, MUCH more information. I would like a FULL WALKTHROUGH of setting up the tool, including EXPLICIT STATEMENTS ABOUT WHAT, IF ANY, RULES FILES NEED TO BE MODIFIED FOR THE BASIC FUNCTIONING OF THE SYSTEM. Not allusions and insinuations about files that may exist and somewhere and might be useful. I'd like to know what the system looks like when it works, and what it looks like when it reverts to fallback behavior, and what causes it to go into fallback mode. We spent all day yesterday trying to figure out how to use the thing. I'd like examples, and though I usually hate tutorial videos, this tool is an excellent case for one because users have absolutely no idea what to expect - what the system looks like when it works, when it fails, etc.

For now we have to go to a system of only allowing one user to work on a scene at a time because it's too complicated to get the tool working, and we don't even understand if it IS working as expected because it isn't clear what it's supposed to be doing. All the documents and references I've found just say stuff like "and BAM! merge problems solved!"

Maybe it's just that our situation is an actual conflict, which necessitates a fallback resolution, which still becomes rapidly too difficult to manually resolve. There does seem to be no technical way to handle actual conflicts... which seems to suggest that a more stable development pattern is to just force different developers to work on different scenes anyway...

 

Any updates on the issue my scene files were having?

 

Hi, I'm getting the following error :





My .gitconfig is like this:

[merge]
tool = unityyamlmerge

[mergetool "unityyamlmerge"]
cmd = 'C:\\Program Files\\Unity\\Unity 2018.1.0f2\\Editor\\Data\\Tools\\UnityYAMLMerge.exe' merge -p "$BASE" "$REMOTE" "$LOCAL" "$MERGED"
trustExitCode = false
keepTemporaries = true
keepBackup = false

Am I doing something wrong? I couldn`t find (or maybe understand) the solution to that reading this thread, so I thought I should ask. Thanks.

 

Getting a strange error with this tool, all I get is:

Deleted merge conflict for 'blablascene.unity':
{local}: deleted
{remote}: deleted

any ideas? it is delete on none of the branches

 

OK so I resolved the issue. I am not 100% sure of the problem, but it seems like the fix was using the latest version of git, rather than the embedded git that was part of sourcetree

 

Ryan,

Is it possible to use the latest version of UnityYAMLMerge.exe, let's say 2017.4.4f1, into a Unity 5.x (5.6.6) installation?

We cannot upgrade our project to 2017 but would like to use the tool with the latest fix. Do you foresee any conflict in doing so or do we have to upgrade?

Thank you.

----

Edit; We've extracted the latest UnityYAMLMerge.exe available from a higher Unity version and are using it in our 5.6.6 project. So far so good. Would still appreciate a confirmation @ryanc-unity if you can. Thank you.

 

I've updated to 2018.3.2f1 and I've still not managed to get unityyamlmerge to actually perform the merge. It still leaves the conflict markers in the supposedly "resolved" file.

 

I am having the same issue

 

SmartMerge seems to mess with our scene.

Environment context
UnityYAMLMerge.exe is setup as a custom Merge Tool in SourceTree, as recommended per the documentation:

Code (CSharp):

1. merge -p $BASE $REMOTE $LOCAL $MERGED

The fallback application is p4merge (Perforce) and handled perfectly through mergespecfile.txt

Unity version: 2017.4.24f1 (LTS)
SourceTree: 3.1.2
Git: 2.21.0
Windows 10 (x64)
P4merge: 2018.4.175.3667

Reproduction scenario
- create a scene with nothing but an empty GameObject that is shared on the Git repository (base)
- a contributor deletes the GameObject, then push on the Git repository (remote)
- another contributor (before pulling) adds a BoxCollider to the same GameObject then commits (local)

-> He now needs to pull and resolve the conflict in order to be able to push

Issues
First issue is when dealing with the 3-way diff on p4merge, the transform component of the GameObject is ommitted on all versions (base, local, remote). Thus, no matter the conflict resolution, SourceTree is staging a Transform component removal that obviously Unity will complain about.

Secondly, the BoxCollider component is present on all three versions (base, local remote) whereas it should only be on the local one. As a result, if I pick the base version Unity output an error because the GameObject is not referencing the BoxCollider that is currently attached to it. And if I pick the remote version, Unity error will be about a BoxCollider referencing a non-existing GameObject.

Unity console errors related to missing transform component:

Code (CSharp):

1. - Broken text PPtr in file(Assets/Scenes/New Scene.unity). Local file identifier (583727351) doesn't exist! (personal note: this is the GUID of the transform component)
2. - Component could not be loaded when loading game object. Cleaning up!
3. - Transform component could not be found on game object. Adding one!
4. - GameObject has multiple Transform components! Merged into single one.

Unity console errors related to unreferenced BoxCollider:

Code (CSharp):

1. - CheckConsistency: GameObject does not reference component BoxCollider. Fixing.

Unity console errors related to unanchored (GameObject destroyed) BoxCollider:

Code (CSharp):

1. - Broken text PPtr in file(Assets/Scenes/New Scene.unity). Local file identifier (583727350) doesn't exist!
2. - BoxCollider component deleted: GameObject pointer is invalid

Attached to this posts, the three .tmp files handled through p4merge.exe, including versions for all resolution choices (picking any version out of local/remote/base)

 

(apologies, if this is redundant/stale information.)

Unity (2018.3.9f1) seems to be leaving "stripped" sections in YAML, when removing PrefabEvolutions scripts in the prefab editor and saving...


--- !u!4 &867059778370281911 stripped
Transform:
m_CorrespondingSourceObject: {fileID: 402950, guid: 26ee827b17674bd49b20f19726073d0f,
type: 3}
m_PrefabInstance: {fileID: 867059778370406321}
m_PrefabAsset: {fileID: 0}


Note also that the YamlDocument for the parent Transform still contains a reference to the stripped component...

--- !u!4 &4623688170425086
Transform:
m_ObjectHideFlags: 0
m_CorrespondingSourceObject: {fileID: 0}
m_PrefabInstance: {fileID: 0}
m_PrefabAsset: {fileID: 0}
m_GameObject: {fileID: 1068550404735368}
m_LocalRotation: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0, w: 1}
m_LocalPosition: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0}
m_LocalScale: {x: 1, y: 1, z: 1}
m_Children:
- {fileID: 867059778370281911}
- {fileID: 4633740666678510}

I haven't found a way to remove these via the Editor (re-importing, etc) so I'm manually removing them. A fix would be appreciated.

- thanks

 

Now that I use Unity Hub for installing different versions of the editor on the same machine, the UnityYAMLMerge tool path changes a lot (each time I change the Unity version), so it's a bit of a chore to remember to check the path and change it in the config file. This could lead to not calling the tool at all if the version in the config file is no longer installed.

For example for Git in Windows, till unity hub the default path was something like:

cmd = 'C:\\Program Files\\Unity\\Editor\\Data\\Tools\\UnityYAMLMerge.exe' merge -p --describe --timing "$BASE" "$REMOTE" "$LOCAL" "$MERGED"

Now for 2019.1.4 it could be something like:

cmd = 'C:\\Program Files\\Unity\\Hub\\Editor\\2019.1.4f1\\Editor\\Data\\Tools\\UnityYAMLMerge.exe' merge -p --describe --timing "$BASE" "$REMOTE" "$LOCAL" "$MERGED"

To work correctly I should change it in every config file in each project every time I upgrade. This is true for any kind of upgrade since it changes the path in any of the following ways:
2019.1.4fX
2019.1.Y.fX
2019.Z.YfX
20W.Z.YfX

Have you guys thought of a way to automate this or make it easier?

 

I have set the Path user variable to contain also

C:\Program Files\Unity\Hub\Editor\x.x.xf1\Editor\Data\Tools

, so I only need to update it, and not change the git config.
Sure it would be nice to have it automatically update whenever I get the latest version, but so would be to have Unity Hub to auto download the latest Unity version.
So it would be a nice thing to have, but imho not that critical, changing one user variable per week is not hard work.

 

It's true that it isn't critical. Anyway it sounds like a good idea, if you have multiple projects only one change (your PATH) is needed. Thanks for the tip!

 

Hello!

I just tried out Smart Merge for the first time today, and it works great!

My question is: is it possible to use environment variables within, or pass other data to "mergespecfile.txt"?

In my setup, a script sets up a few variables in the developers' system. Ex. we call

SETX %GAME_ROOT%=%~dp0

to set the root directory for tools scripts, etc.

In order to minimize setup time and external dependencies, I like to ship my merge tool within my repo. Right now, I'm using DiffMerge and have it committed under

%GAME_ROOT%\tools\DiffMerge\

So, in my fallback, I'd like to do something like:

unity use "%GAME_ROOT%tools\DiffMerge\sgdm.exe" ....
prefab use "%GAME_ROOT%tools\DiffMerge\sgdm.exe" ....

# Local DiffMerge
* use "%GAME_ROOT%tools\DiffMerge\sgdm.exe" ....


Is this possible?

 

Hi, can anyone shed light on this thread? Haven't heard from anyone:
https://forum.unity.com/threads/smartmerge-nuking-prefab.915464/

I heard this is the place to post on these issues (4 years too late):
https://www.reddit.com/r/Unity3D/co...ve_scene_conflicts_with_unitys_smart/cvlko5r/

 

Bump

 

Please don't let this thread die.

 

It seems the folks at Unity have stopped monitoring this: @ryanc-unity, @jdrewsen, @khris1rino - can we get an update please?

Using Unity 2019.3.12f1 - Are the instructions in the mergespecfile.txt 100% accurate? I have attached the copy I use and it says the following at the top:

# %l is replaced with the path of you local version
# %r is replaced with the path of the incoming remote version
# %b is replaced with the common base version
# %d is replaced with a path where the result should be written to

The problem I am running into is that when using Meld v3.20.2 to perform a 3way merge as my fallback merge tool, here is the command I have:

unity use "%programs%\Meld\meld.exe" "%l" "%b" "%r" -o "%d" --auto-merge
prefab use "%programs%\Meld\meld.exe" "%l" "%b" "%r" -o "%d" --auto-merge
* use "%programs%\Meld\meld.exe" "%l" "%b" "%r" -o "%d" --auto-merge

The results for %l and %r are being swapped. The left window (%l) shows the REMOTE contents, the middle window (%b) shows the BASE contents, and the right window (%r) shows the LOCAL contents. Are we sure that %l doesn't correspond to LEFT (theirs) and %r doesn't correspond to RIGHT (mine) as it does for the -l and -r parameters when using UnityYAMLMerge? I have attached a screenshot of the console using UnityYAMLMerge and here is a copy/paste of the instructions from UnityYAMLMerge using the command line:

Unity YAML Merge Tool for scene or prefab files - version 1.0.1
usage: UnityYAMLMerge merge [-l|-r|-p|-h] [-i file] [-o file]
[--rules rulesfile]
[--fallback fallbackspecfile]
[--force] [--describe]
<base> <left> <right> [dest]
[premerge base dest] [premerge right dest]
-l Resolve merge conflicts using left (theirs)
-r Resolve merge conflicts using right (mine)
-i file Resolve merge conflicts using merge file
-o file File to write merge conflicts into
-p Use premerging
-h Use 'headless' mode (no error dialogs)
--rules A files with merge rules
--typeInfo A file with type information on objects in asset files
--fallback Spec file defining fallback tools on conflicts if not using
builtin. Can be set to 'none' to disable fallback.
--force Force merging even on unknown file extensions
--describe Include description of what has been done in the -o file.

This is further evidenced by the fact that when I do not use a "merge -p" command and just use "merge" when running UnityYAMLMerge on a commit with a Scene named "Town", it opens the temporary "Town_LOCAL" Scene file (that UnityYAMLMerge creates in my Unity project along with the Town_BACKUP, Town_REMOTE, and Town_BASE files), on the right window in Meld which is supposed to be the %r parameter for the REMOTE file (theirs).

Also, if you watch this video here, I am using the same setup that he is and you will note he has "%r" "%b" "%l" in that order for Meld and only then is he able to get LOCAL to show upon the left despite "%r" being labeled as REMOTE:

 

@ryanc-unity, @jdrewsen, @khris1rino - can I please get an update from you all on this or can you please direct this to the person now responsible for maintaining UnityYAMLMerge?

 

DId someone received YamlMerge.exe Bad allocation errror? It happened in our main prefab (large prefab, and there seems to be 50+ commits on it in the last few days) and now we can't proceed wihout it(

 

I am using git and use UnityYAMLMerge for resolving merge conflicts (as mergetool).
I receive following error when UnityYAMLMerge tries to merge conflicts:
"Cannot find transform parent for fileID"


Unity Version: 2019.2.19f1

Do you have any idea how can I solve this issue?