Search Unity

  1. Welcome to the Unity Forums! Please take the time to read our Code of Conduct to familiarize yourself with the forum rules and how to post constructively.
  2. We’re making changes to the Unity Runtime Fee pricing policy that we announced on September 12th. Access our latest thread for more information!
    Dismiss Notice
  3. Dismiss Notice

Question Optimizing HDRP for VR is a pain: a thread

Discussion in 'High Definition Render Pipeline' started by carcasanchez, Jan 15, 2020.

  1. carcasanchez


    Jul 15, 2018
    Hello, fellow Uniters.

    I am working in a VR simulation of a concert for a College investigation. Having a very high end target hardware (GTX 2080) and aspiring to top graphics, I moved the project to HDRP (version 2019.3.f03, using HTC vive).

    Moreover, after see this Unite presentation (especially with the 24:30 demo), I was excited about how the graphics could improve with this new technology.

    This is a glimpse of the simulation I am building upload_2020-1-15_16-49-25.png
    Althogh being satisfied with the graphic aspect of it, the more I work on the Pipeline, the more lost I am.
    Specific features, like real-time shadows and VFX graph particles, are very demanding even with minimal setup. Even if I only have two or three very low-res realtime shadows (with no extra features that could be too heavy) or a very humble smoke effect, performance goes from rock-solid 90 fps, to oscillating 45-60. I know that VR has very hard limitations, but its difficult to me to believe that it can't handle a simple VFX graph, knowing that my hardware is very powerful.
    Usually, I would just shrug and try to optimize the scene as usual, but the HDRP puts some issues onto the table:

    -Most optimizations I did (like GPU instancing, static batching, baking materials in all, using simple shaders, etc), although reducing Draw Calls, have no visible effect at improving framerate.
    -Profiling tools (Like frame debugger, or GPU profiling) are very cryptic to me
    -Documentation, tutorials and demos are very scarce, and makes information gathering very harsh.

    This is what my profiler looks ike

    Seems obvious that I am GPU bounded, but I have troubles isolating the cause, since is very erratic. Things that, sometimes, drop performance, start to work propery with no apparent reason. I don't know what I can disable in the HDRP options, since I am unable to find explanations about how nothing works and impacts on rendering.

    Another option I have been toying with is modify the Render Pipeline by myself to elliminate all the aspect I don't need in the simulation, but, again, lack of documentation, tutorials and user experiences pushed me back from this.

    Right now, I am in a uncertain situation. I am unsure if this is my fault for throwing expensive things into the scene, if things like VFX graph are in fact not intended to work in VR, what other optimizations I can implement, what is causing the overhead, if this is just due to the young nature of the HDRP, and what improving margin I can hope for by just waiting for Unity Technologies to optimize and improve the pipeline.

    I will gladly accept any suggestion about what could be the way to go: dropping HDRP (although I will regret to lose all these cool graphics updates) and using something more low-to-the-ground, or just waiting for the pipeline to mature (mind that my project is not in a hurry, and I can work without the more demanding features by now).

    I will be infinitelty grateful, of course, if you could provide any insight/documentation about HDRP features, since I am 70% convinced that I am making a huge setup mistake that causes the performance loss.

    So, thank you in advance.

    EDIT: if you want more context about my insecurities about HDRP optimization, check this thread I posted yesterday