Optimal size for animation (sprite sheet) particle system texture?

I want to make sprite sheet for Texture Sheet Animation module.
I see the sample from Standard Asset: ParticleFlameLickSheet.png (256x2048)




According to Art Asset best practice guide
"If you author your textures to a power of two (for example, 512x512 or 256x1024), the textures will be more efficient and won’t need rescaling at build time."

So I want to confirm: as long as it's power of two, square texture (for example: 512x512, 1024x1024, 2048x2048,...) and rectangle texture (for example: 8x2048, 32x2048, 256x2048,...) are both optimal for sprite sheet texture size in term of frame-rate performance?
I want to confirm so that I can comfortably make 8x2048 texture without worrying about it might be slower than the rectangle 2048x2048.

Thanks.

 

Yep, it's fine.*

* Except when it isn't. Some texture formats can only be square, like PVRTC for iOS devices, or may use a square power of two worth of memory on the GPU for some GPU models & texture formats. Really though, I wouldn't worry too much about it if PC is your target platform.

Also in no situation will 8x2048 be slower than 2048x2048, but it is possible a 128x128 could be faster.

 

Thank bgolus, I need to clarify this:
so 8x2048 = 16,384
128x128 = 16,384
so 128x128 is possible faster than 8x2048, but in theory, 128x128 is not faster (nor slower) than 8x2048.
Do I understand it correctly?

 

Correct. Basically if you've got a GPU that internally stores textures as the next largest power of 2, and your rendering is memory bandwidth limited, then 128x128 may be faster than 8x2048.

How much faster? Probably not enough that you'd notice a difference on dedicated PC GPU even in the worst case. Mobile worst case could actually be significant.

Really, I'd say don't worry about it unless it becomes an issue. There are tools out there for automatically slicing and re-laying out flipbooks, including one from Unity.

 

Does unity3d has tool for creating flipbooks from separate textures ?

 

https://blogs.unity3d.com/2016/11/28/free-vfx-image-sequences-flipbooks/

 

Bless you.
I was searching for this blog for about few weeks now.

 

But what is the status of this.
Is this even working on unity3d 2020.2 ?
Is this going to be built in ?

 

Status is it hasn’t been updated since 2017, but it should work still. Otherwise there are a handful of tools out there, or even free gimp / photoshop actions.

 

Unfortunately clicking on a links directs me to the blank page.

 

Thank you @richardkettlewell !

It is a really useful tool, even if not a lot of people use it, and if the particle system sprite support partial supersedes some of the necessity of having one. I've used a lot of tools to do flipbooks in the past, and it's honestly one of the best not-for-pay ones I've ever used.

The absolute best tool I've played with for this task would be Facedown FX's Slate Editor.
https://www.facedownfx.com/
But that's $150 for any non-personal use, and has more bells and whistles than most people need.

 

Sorry for the inconvenience, indeed, our file sharing service have been decommissioned.

If you want to access VFX Toolbox, it is now available as a package at GitHub : https://github.com/Unity-Technologies/VFXToolbox

It is now compatible with 2019.3 and later, and maintained. If you exeperience bugs, feel free to report them to the issues section of this github repository.