Feedback Night scene lighting. Pick one

Hello, I'm looking for some feedback regarding lighting my scene at night. Here's two different versions. What do yall think?

 

2nd... But I can't quite figure out where the orange light is coming from. Maybe a compromise between the two.

My brain is telling me "something is casting an orange light", but because I don't actually see the object it's a little bit jarring.

 

Thanks, the plan is to have a lot of fires but I may have to turn it down in the end.