Making keyboard and controller controls feel the same

I noticed that the controls between keyboard and controller feel different from each other. The keyboard one feels a bit smoother while the controller controls are a bit too abrupt. I can do the same with both but that's not the issue here. How can I make that the controller controls feel the same as the keyboard ones? I already tested to set the options in the Input Manager to the same values as the keyboard ones but it didn't work.

Those are the settings right now.