Losing Controller in One of Two Action Maps

I am using the default UI action map alongside my own custom one. UI is for the menus, the other is for gameplay. With a XBox One Wireless USB Controller, I have found that sometimes when the controller shuts off automatically during an editor session, once I turn on the controller again, the gameplay Action Map stops working while the UI one continues to work fine.

My only current workaround is to restart the editor. Power cycling the controller does not fix it. I have not tried unplugging/replugging the USB wireless dongle as it is out of reach.

Can someone offer some guidance on how to debug this?