Issue with HDR not working in GameView but in SceneView

Hopefully someone can help me out here.

Problem is that HDR is just working fine in the SceneView, but not in the GameView.
All is set up for HDR, allowHDR on camera and useHDR in project settings.
Color space in linear, Image effect both work in SceneView and GameView.
There is no difference in forward or deferred rendering mode. And the issue persists on other projects. (e.g. Standard Assets examples)

With the frame debugger I noticed that the BlitCopy Shader seems to mess the HDR up?
Maybe someone can help we out and tell me whats going on here?

See the pics:
Note: I don't use Image Effects in the scene here, but that doesn't change the outcome.
SceneView (Top)
GameView (Bottom)

Image1: HDR not applied or reverted by BlitCopy Shader (?)


Image 2: HDR looks correct, just before the Blit Shader.

I'm clueless to how to fix that.
Any suggestions?

 

The tonemapping should be part of the Image Effects. If you don't have any Image Effects, Unity will apply a standard tonemapping. If you do have have any Image Effect, it's up to the Image Effects to do the tonemapping. So, setting a BlitCopy as Image Effect will remove the standard tonemapping.

 

Thanks.

Thing is, there is no difference if I use an non standard tonemapping effect or not, e.g. from the Post Processing Stack.
The non standard tonemapping works totally as expected, I don't know about the standard tonemapping, but I would expect it to have equal results in the SceneView and in the GameView?
BlitCopy is just supposed to copy over an image 1:1 right? I don't get how it can alter the output, unless it gets the maybe wrong input.

Here are now images with Post Image Effects Applied. (Bloom and Color Grading).

Top is SceneView and Bottom is GameView.

How it should look like: right Before BlitCopy


How it should NOT look like: right after BlitCopy


Any other ideas?

Is the BlitCopy supposed to be there?

 

Right, and looking at the source, that is what it does. I don't really think it's needed there and the reason for the difference might be a linear/sRGB conversion.

 

Alright jvoc3dc, thanks.
I have absolutly no idea how I can fix the issue. Hopefully it will magically be fixed with the coming releases, until then I have to live without HDR. :/

 

i have the same problem but in android project...

Then i go to the:

edit - project settings - graphic and found this

http://take.ms/ficlO

After i just turn on all needed settings:
http://take.ms/Ojtcb

And HDR work now!

I didn't expect than half of important settings was disabled!!!

Sorry for my English, hope its help

 

Hey Nasa13,
thanks for the tip, I tested all settings, but they don't have any effect on the GamveView rendering.
My problem persists. :/

 

update: The problem went away with 2017.1.1p3

 

I have the same issue on 2018.2f version........ I did all the setting to HDR and other tricks, but nothing happened

 

Thanks! That totally worked on 2018.1.3

 

Thanks man!

 

Will you marry me???