Feedback Is there anyone has success with LWRP SRP batching on andriod?

I have tried 2018.4.6, 2019.1.14, 2019.2.2, with Samsung Galaxy S6, Google Nexus 6P, LG G4, and none of them work on Andriod. However, on IOS, it works flawlessly.

According to the documents below:
- https://docs.unity3d.com/Manual/SRPBatcher.html
- https://blogs.unity3d.com/2019/02/28/srp-batcher-speed-up-your-rendering/

It should be available for 2019.1 and/or 2019.2 for OpenGL ES 3.1 and higher, however, this is not the case from what I see.

There are other similar post said that this has been fixed but not from what I see:
- https://forum.unity.com/threads/lwrp-srp-batcher-not-work-on-mobile.676705/
- https://forum.unity.com/threads/srp-batcher-issues-on-android-lwrp.696599/

 

Hey aleksandrk.

Thanks for your reply. So does that mean it should work in 2019.1 or currently it is not working in ANY version? I have tested it on multiple versions of unity and Andriod devices as mentioned above. My problem is not about positions set to 0, the problem is that it has no performance improvements (actually it worsen the performance when SRP batching is on) on andriod devices. I am quite sure my test scene set up is correct as it is working as intended on IOS devices.

 

Ok, I will test out 2019.1 again and see if it actually works.

Samsung Galaxy S6, Google Nexus 6P, LG G4, they should all be Open GL 3.1+ If I am correct?

Sorry if you have misunderstood what I was trying to say. I am not a native English speaker.
"None of them work" as in I have tried those versions of Unity and enabling SRP Batching, but there is no impact on improving the performance at all for the Andriod devices I mentioned. But it works fine on IOS.

 

https://issuetracker.unity3d.com/issues/android-lwrp-some-meshes-are-rendered-in-black-color
Is this issue fixed? We are having this issue in our project which causes corrupt/wrong lightmapping, it only happens when SRP batcher is on and on Android. No problem on iOS or PC

 

Vulkan and OpenGLES3

Well, I created a test project specifically for testing this feature. And it works flawlessly on IOS. If you insist that the SRP Batcher for Andriod is working as intended, then I would say this is not production-ready for me.

Thank you for your answers. I will turn off SRP Batching and stick to the old fashion way with dynamic and static batching.

 

Found out why my android game was lagging and giving me high vertex reading only on android but not on the editor, the srp batcher doesnt work on android (unity 2019.4)

 

It's does
But not every shader is compatible with it

 

I am using the URP Lit shader, check out my topic
https://forum.unity.com/threads/absurd-vertices-on-android-but-not-on-the-editor.914501/

It works when profiling on the editor and reduces drastically the verts count but on the android mobile it gives me the full verts like when i disable the SRP batcher on the editor runtime.

 

The stats window is messed up when using SRP Batcher, sometimes it's showing negative numbers
There is script here on the forum that show SRP Batcher stats just look for it

 

And batching does not reduce vert count but draw calls
You should read a bit more about that

 

So the profiler is bugged when it comes to profile the srp because when i enable SRP the verts goes down and the draw calls goes up and when i disable it the draw calls comes down and the verts goes up.
It's sad that simple square cubes and some planes takes up so much performance to be rendered on unity mobile but i guess it's just the way it is.

 

Yes you shouldn't rely on it
Which device are you using for these test and is post processing enabled ?
And why don't you test on real project ? Coz we have something which is in development right now and it's works pretty well I would say

 

URP and every graphics on low without post processing and with downgrade in resolution, it seems that rendering too much square blocks gives too much vertices for the device to handle properly.

Testing on an ~mid end android device motorola g4 plus octa core (antutu says that is faster than 51% of the smartphones they test) so is right in the middle, i'm not testing on the iphone because its fast and can run basically anything...
I'm going to add more complex 3d models on top of that square blocks but i guess i'll follow up with the development and if it only runs right on high end devices it's the risk i'll have to take.
Thanks for the help!

 

You're is weak seriously it's has Adreno 405 GPU
How many triangles are you trying to render ?
https://forum.unity.com/threads/per...ions-of-unity-post-processing-and-srp.786944/
Look at this thread you will find some tests I've made for stressing LWRP and URP