Is it possible to rename objects that are animated

For example, The animation of "GameObject" - I have a lot of animations that use this name, is it possible to rename them without recreating all my animations?

http://gyazo.com/4d7ed557fb47f5ff6bc255222de88911

 

Isn't this extremely counter-intuitive? Can't you add a functionality to set a new path for the animation curve?

 

What's the name of this script? Link?

 

Got this issue yet again, and found the tool @Mecanim.Dev was talking about :
https://github.com/s-m-k/Unity-Animation-Hierarchy-Editor

Still, people using the animation window don't necessary know how to code, so having it available by the API won't help them much..

Now that there are tools to fix it, if it won't be integrated in the engine, you could at least put a more helpful description when a renaming is detected, pointing to an actual solution like this github.

 

This script is not a robust solution, as with rotation keyframes it will create keyframes for all time points, effectively destroying precisely created hand animations. The function used and API seem to imply this may intended behavior. Anyway, it really sucks that you can't rename objects you've animated... And just saying 'we have an API that should do it' without proper testing of a full solution really means 'we're confident it's not yet provably impossible'.

I'm on board with relying on community for stuff, and building great APIs for them to do so, but renaming/relinking is far too basic of functionality for this kind of outsourcing. I'm not even trying to change hierarchy, just rename them (it lets you attempt to rename in animation window, but that's bugged also).

 

Yeah this has been an issue for a long time.
The workaround I used now is to open the anim clip using a text editor or Mono Develop and manually replace game object name. Remember to use Replace All .

I think asset serialization must be Force Text. And make sure you made a copy of anim clip, just in case.

 

Workaround with open anim clip in text editor and "replace all" corrupts the files, so Unity can't use them. Unity-Animation-Hierarchy-Editor works, but it fills every animation frame with value. Only solution that works for me is to copy and paste curves values from one property to another.

 

Best non-Unity solution.
Anybody having hierarchical assets (characters) created by in house or contract artists need to request and require proper naming conventions from inception of a characters concept/design all the way to authoring/exporting to ensure this isn't a problem once in development in Unity.

Important to check hierarchies and ask for changes when the results are generic bone001/null001/bip001 naming conventions on character rigs.
Its unfortunate theres no way to inspect a character hierarchy structure for proper naming in the asset store package contents display.

 

I also had this problem, after moving some files inside the Hierarchy.

I don't think that the fact there is a script is a good solution, nor it's compatible with Unity principle of ease of use. The advantage of moving and renaming things inside Unity is that Unity automatically rebinds almost anything.

In theory you can do anything by API, code and external tools. Even have an entire engine by external tools. But then what would be the use of Unity? The theory is the same, I think it's a dissonance from the rest of Unity ease of use principles.

 

Has there been any progress on this?

Not being able to rename or change the hierarchy of objects without completely breaking animations is very limiting to the creative process. I am an animator by profession, who recently dove into Unity. This is basic stuff in any animation package.

Changing structure and names is often required after creative choices are made. Planning ahead doesn't always cut it.

At least there should be a quick way to relink 'lost' object to other objects.

 

+1 to the sentiments here.

Perhaps you could detail why this is even hard to do, from a technical perspective.

Can't you have an internal ID and use the name as a "friendly name" and then have a simple hash table that gets updated when a name is changed?

Why is making the name of something, a very unstable value, the ID a good thing?

 

+1 for animation binding by object ID based
animation shouldn't depending to object string name, this is the reason why unity animation tool are neglected for intermediate(or above) animation stuff

 

+1 for ID-bound animation

Why the hell would you not use the powerful and (basically) foolproof serialization engine Unity is built on?

 

+1 Animating UI is incredibly time consuming & frustrating because of basic issues like this. We need to be able to restructure without having to recreate everything.

 

Has anybody filed a bug report or feedback suggestion for this?
If so please update here with the case number or feedback link.
I have GOOD points to vote on a worthy update such as this - now that the forum changed back to useful version.

 

Seems doable for me

 

I agree.

We use mecanim for all our Canvas UI animations.
Using paths is very brittle but I agree is the best way to allow for reusable animations.
Especially with UI animations the target path can be a complicated structure that needs to change later when functionality is added. We try to layer animations to target as little as possible but major structure changes are sometimes necessary to support new layout and functions.

Based on my experience providing a simple way to just rename path would be absolutely perfect.
Allow target paths to be renamed directly in the animation window using the usual F2 (Win) or Enter (Mac).

We generally just force text serialization and manually find an replace the paths in the .anim files. Which works great for us at the moment but a more user friendly editor approach would be nice and relativity simple to implement.

 

@DavidGeoffroy Thanks for the detailed explanation, makes sense, I don't live in the FBX curved based world at all so this never crossed my mind. Perhaps this is too bold, but is your solution too ideal? As in it would indeed be great, but currently we have nothing, so wouldn't a gap stop be helpful to at least some people?

Perhaps a UI layer on top of what @pixelbob is doing? Then your more robust solution?

Just a thot. Cheers!

 

Hey,
any news on that matter?

Can I remap automatically now?
Can I change name of object so it does not crush animation?

 

What I'd like to see is an optional component for the game object with Animator attached that maps the animation data as a channel to one or more game objects, thus removing the dependency on hierarchy or name. This would not only eliminate the renaming issues, but if you wanted to have a channel apply to multiple game objects, you could. For instance, if I wanted a generic animation state that played when something took damage, and caused lights to flicker, I could animate an object called lights, and upon usage, it could be mapped to glowing eyes on a humanoid robot, or a truck's front and back lights, etc.

So internally, when I start animating something, it assigns an ID along with the name of the curve data stream as it currently does. Then changing the name would still break path based links, but if using the mapping component, the clip could change name and hierarchy without breaking any usage, as could the usage.

This could also allow for the animation of things outside it's hierarchy, if a script linked the mapping to it. So, for instance, you could have the ability to pick up melee weapons, and if the weapon has a mapping component with channel data for glow or something, then the melee attack could have the glow timing, intensity, and color all in it's clip data where it should be, without the need to write a translator component to pump those animated values to the weapon, since the mapping component does that naturally.

Unity's animation system seems so close to that 'animate anything' that it's marketing material says... or at least at present even if you can technically animate anything... you almost assuredly shouldn't. Stuff like this, I think, could help fix that.

 

This may not actually address the issue as directly as many would like, but what about something as simple as being able to add "Notes" or a "Nickname" to a game object in the hierarchy/animation window..? The problem for me is that I've used a lot of free assets made by other indie developers, and while many can and do produce quality content, they also don't always use proper naming conventions for their assets.

Getting an asset that serves my needs but every part of its armature is named "Box#" or "IK#" is rather disappointing. If I we could apply nicknames that are only useful as an interface with the developers and have no other bearing on a project (I.E Only exists as a marker within the editor UI and is not considered, evaluated or used in any other way) it would alleviate a lot of the troubles of needing to rename objects that are already animated.

 

The solution is quite simple, really.

When in Animation window, like when you click on Add Property and the properties hierarchy window pops up, you could simply add an Edit Property option when right clicking the "yellow missing" property and a new properties hierarchy window would pop up. Only the properties with the needed type could be shown, and... it's done! Why the fuss, I don't get it.

 

Should note that it goes in Assets/Editors. Use the console to figure out errors.

 

Is this still an issue? A little discouraged to be experiencing this problem and see that the original post was created in 2014. I'm running into a problem where I have a complex fbx, but a lot of things like bolts/nuts are named just "bolt" or "nut". I thought that a rename would help me organize and find meshes better but it breaks the animation link and the animation panel is "missing". Is there a way to click in the projects hierarchy panel and have the object highlighted in the animation panel (I know it works the opposite way...click an object in the animation panel and it highlights in the hierarchy panel.) If both selections would/could be synced that would go a long way to helping my main issue of finding objects in these panels.
Just to add to the sentiment here, this is unfortunate "gotcha" for Unity3d. It is really out of the ordinary for Unity3d environment to not be flexible.

 

Resorting to large text because this has been a problem for years.

Please fix this:
Simply add a way to right-click on a property with a broken link for an option to specify a new path. (You already show the path in the hovertip, just let us edit it!)

It's incredibly simple. The fix on he asset store is just a single file. But it should be built in. Please. And thank you.

 

@Mecanim-Dev This is great! Would be even better if you could drag and drop the game object to the animation track.

 

Fantastic!

 

Circling back to this thread with an alternative approach for refactoring the elements in an animation.

If you serialize your project assets as 'Forced Text'

Edit > Project Settings > Editor : Asset Serialization = Forced Text

Then you can open an animation FooAnim.anim and edit the path to a specific element directly.

All .anim files are serialized using a YAML format, and are pretty easy to read. If you have a text editor like VS Code, a bulk search and replace along with a little bit of regular expression usage can make refactoring pretty easy.

Consider wanting to add a 'Neck' element between existing 'Head' and 'Chest' elements. The current path to 'Head' looks something like Pelvis/Chest/Head see the below text version of an .anim file...

Code (csharp):

1.  
2. - curve:
3.       serializedVersion: 2
4.       m_Curve:
5.       - serializedVersion: 2
6.         time: 0
7.         value: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0.111445256, w: 0.9937706}
8.         inSlope: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0, w: 0}
9.         outSlope: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0, w: 0}
10.         tangentMode: 0
11.  
12.         ... SNIPPED OTHER CURVE INFO ...    
13.  
14.       - serializedVersion: 2
15.         time: 2
16.         value: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0.111445256, w: 0.9937706}
17.         inSlope: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0, w: 0}
18.         outSlope: {x: 0, y: 0, z: 0, w: 0}
19.         tangentMode: 0
20.       m_PreInfinity: 2
21.       m_PostInfinity: 2
22.       m_RotationOrder: 4
23.     path: Pelvis/Chest/Head
24.  

To refactor 'Head' to be under 'Neck' you can simple edit the text after path. This may cause the look of your animation to be off as now 'Head' will be animating relative to 'Neck', and you'll have to do this path replace everywhere, but I find doing it via text find-replace is much faster than manually opening dozens or hundreds of animations and editing them by hand.

FWIW, you can also do this with the positioning, rotation, etc of an element -- although this is more time consuming as this is all encoded as curve information which so far as I can tell is defined in multiple locations within the .anim file.

Anyways, hopefully that helps someone.

 

This solution is no longer available in 5.6.3p1 (the one I'm using).
Or... I have no idea why. The animation is just a sprite renderer changing sprites.

 

2017.2.0f3 and still no luck. Althought it worked the first day I installed the new version, the next one it just stopped.
It's a random bug I guess and needs a lot of testing. But I still believe my suggestion would solve this issue:

 

Yes this option is gone for some reason even in version 2017.3

 

I've been testing every kind of click possible and it still doesn't work, I'm on windows 10 and the same Unity version as you are.
I must be doing something wrong here, but I have no idea what, It just doesn't appear for some reason.

 

I'm not sure what you mean with the 2nd question, my animator is on the "Bowman" gameobject.
I'm not using Mecanim with skinned meshes, only with 2D sprites and animating script values.

As far as I understand it there's no particular sequence of operations that led me to not seeing this rename option, with all the stuff I've done in the Animation window I would've noticed the moment I could rename. I just never was able to do it, that's it.
To make extra sure I created a new project and replicated what you did, no rename still. (there's just one hierarchy asset in that project but it's not the cause of the problem).

 

Hello @Mecanim-Dev@DavidGeoffroy
I have an urgent question please help me. We are working on a animation project. When I change object hierarchy (parenting) animation positions changes. Animation characteristics changes. How can I solve this problem? Please write me soon because this is a dead lined project.

 

Hi @Mecanim-Dev,@Joachim_Ante @DavidGeoffroy
You guys aware of unity's animation window is worst and most useless animation window among any others(unreal,3ds max,blender,etc) right? I am now working on a project that animates an induestrial equipment that contains many parts. And this is completely impossible with unity. After so long time with unity, I am dissapointed. I seriously think to switch unreal. Because I tried same thing with unreal and it has many advantages such as I can change parent child hierarchy in animation window of unreal. And many many advantages. If I were you, I take those advices...

 

I have found https://forum.unity.com/threads/constraints-animation-feature-feedback.497445/ forum. Thanks for your quick response

 

I really need to change an animationclip's property's path (to the bone in the hierarchy) AT RUNTIME, OUTSIDE THE EDITOR yet it doesn't seem to be possible, you can only use SetCurve to create a new curve with associated path, but not edit an existing one. I wish this would be made available via script.

 

You can open file animation .anim (it is just a text file with format like json) and you could see "path" key for each object. Change it follow new name/path.

 

I assume that the anim file wouldn't be available with a build?

 

Just add a context menu option to the property that renames the path or transform+path...
such a lazy response... to have every user write a script or download a 3rd party package is totally irresponsible - sure it's a solution today, but be accountable for your own engine and your user's feature requests. It's insane the amount of work put into this window and this simple issue has been a problem since I started using Unity 6 years ago. Unity isn't an open-source project - don't depend on 3rd party assets to fix core engine features.

I feel bad for all the animators who do not know how to code and have to then bring in 3rd party assets to do a basic engine function.