Graphic Raycaster used to have a priority?

I have this same problem. I have two canvases in world space. The second canvas has a button that cannot be clicked when running under 4.6.1. It was working in 4.6.0.

I have installed 4.6.1p2, but it's still not working. I tried playing with the setting in both canvases and changing the z order and the order in the layer, but nothing seems to change. Am I missing something? What do I need to do to make this work?

 

I've just finished tried with the branch patch but it didn't work. Neither

or

worked for me so I suppose that I will wait for version 4.6.2 while I'm still checking this thread.
Thanks everybody for your help!

 

This worked perfectly for me, create the c# file named WorldRaycaster.cs . Place the code below in it. Replace your graphics raycaster component with this file and BAM it works haha

Code (CSharp):

1. using UnityEngine;
2. using UnityEngine.UI;
3. using System.Collections;
4.  
5. public class WorldRaycaster : GraphicRaycaster
6. {
7.     public override int sortOrderPriority
8.     {
9.         get
10.         {
11.             if(GetComponent<Canvas>().renderMode == RenderMode.ScreenSpaceOverlay
12.                || GetComponent<Canvas>().renderMode == RenderMode.ScreenSpaceCamera)
13.             {
14.                 return GetComponent<Canvas>().sortingOrder;
15.             }
16.  
17.             return base.sortOrderPriority;
18.         }
19.     }
20. }

I will just use this till Unity officially fixes it I guess

 

I have a similar situation. One canvas (screen space - camera) is part of the scene from the start (controls the core UI screen flow), then I have dialogs that are instantiated from prefabs and have their own canvas, also screen space - camera.

Originally they were on the same sorting layer with the core canvas at 100 sort order and dialogs at 200. I wanted to dim the background and let touches outside the dialog frame dismiss the dialog so I created a full-screen, mostly transparent button behind the dialog panel as part of the dialog's canvas.

Oddly the controls directly on the dialog (the "OK" button for example) worked, but the fullscreen button wouldn't receive a click. Further, buttons on the core canvas below it were responding to mouseovers and clicks, even with Block Objects set to 'All' on the dialog canvas.

I attempted to apply the WorldRaycaster workaround above, and it worked; but only if I ultimately put the dialogs on another sortingLayer *AND* it had to have a lower sort order than the core canvas, even though they were on totally different sortingLayers, which I imagine shouldn't have any effect if things were working properly.

Phil, I'm on 4.6.1p5; is any of your branch stuff in this patch release? If so, I guess I have another use-case not covered. If not, I'd like to try yours to see if it fixes my specific problem.

 

Not fixed in 4.6.2.

 

Hi @phil-Unity ,

Thanks for monitoring this thread. I have followed the directions with your bitbucket update, but I'm still having the issue where canvases and their children are not processed according to their order in the hierarchy. I've created a sample project and attached it here. Please let me know if you get different behavior with your current version, and if not, how I might fix it.

 

So, i read that it is fixed... but at this moment, i have version 4.6.1p5 and it seems to still not work. I have the same problem exactly like Rakkarage wrote at the beginning of this post from 2 months ago =(

 

Hi @phil-Unity,

I assume you are not talking about the hierarchy order, and I also assume you are not talking about z, since the project illustrates that both those approaches don't work. What order should I make explicit?

 

4.6.2p1 fixed my issues. Thanks!

 

Great to hear this issue is resolved @phil-Unity Fantastic work!

 

@phil-Unity I still see an issue with two canvases in the scene when they're on different Sorting Layers.

My sorting layers are implemented as:
background
Default
gameplay
ui
dialogs

I have my main UI (Screen Space - Camera) on sorting layer "ui" at Order in Layer set at 100. I instantiate dialog prefabs with their own canvas (still Screen Space - Camera) on Sorting Layer "dialogs", Order in Layer set at 1.

The raycasts hit the main UI elements first despite the dialogs being closer to the camera. If I switch the Sorting Layer on dialog's Canvas to the "ui" and bump the Order in Layer to 101, then the dialog gets the raycasts first. I also tried just setting the dialog to order 101 without changing the Sorting Layer but that didn't work.

 

Looking into the UI source and doing some debugging, I think there's an issue with the raycaster's interpretation of the Sorting Layer. BTW, this is on 5.0.0RC3.

I dumped the contents of RaycastResult several times and found that the order appears bugged based on the order of the Sorting Layer's *uniqueId* as an int, not the actual sorting layer order in the layer list. Here's what I found:

My layers:
background (ID: 3395587757)
Default (ID: 0)
gameplay (ID: 2003661311)
ui (ID: 1293112713)
dialogs (ID: 2711576737)

When I dump RaycastResult when my dialog is on the "dialogs" layer, the ID returned by RaycastResult, at least as output to the log, is -1583390559 I assume since it's signed. In this configuration the dialog gets the raycast last, behidn the normal UI which is on the "ui" layer. As I said before, if I move the dialog canvas to the "ui" layer (and put the order-in-layer high enough) it works as expected.

The odd part (and the basis of my guess as to what's wrong), is if I move the dialog canvas to the "gameplay" layer which is behind the "ui" layer, it disappears visually (as it should), but the RaycastResult returns it *first*, and the dialog receives the click. I'll file a bug on this now, but figured you'd want to know since you've been in the code recently.

 

Pretty much confirmed: If I go into Unity's Debug mode and change the UniqueID of the "dialogs" Sorting Layer to 2011576737 (which doesn't flip negative since it's below the signed int threshold) then the dialog box starts receiving the raycast first as expected.

 

Awesome, thanks Phil! BTW, I had filed a bug, case #675139 so you can mark it resolved.

 

Great news @phil-Unity there have been a fair few reports of the CanvasGroup not blocking raycasting in to a 3D scene.

 

So I have the same issue with some of my Sorting Layers. I assume it's not a good idea to fiddle the the sorting layer IDs though?

 

My problem is also connected and still unsolved. http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/physics2draycaster-and-camera.286317/#post-2042060 I don't repeat it all in detail, but in that post all my tests and details on the problem.

 

I also have this problem, I not able manage clicks on different canvas. Only if them are with same sortingLayer, then I can control them changing layerOrder, but this is not good for my logic.

 

This also happens to me, but instead of it being a button on top of an other i have a canvas on top of my buttons, is there a way to fix it or do i also have to wait for the patch?