Best HTTP Released

@BestHTTP

Hello.
I got problem with freeing memory:

When i download file i can't unload it from my memory.

Already tryed disable cookies, cache.

Define Symbols:
BESTHTTP_DISABLE_ALTERNATE_SSL;BESTHTTP_DISABLE_COOKIES;BESTHTTP_DISABLE_CACHING

Here code:
https://pastebin.com/sVTrqyTs



I think I'm making smth wrong but I tried almost everything.

 

@yathish9158

With what protocol are you using it? Websocket itself has no reconnect logic.

You can set the plugin's log level to All and send the produced log to so i can see what's happening. However, if there's poor network conditions it's not guaranteed that the plugin can reconnect to the server if it could previously.

 

@Ivvova

1.) There's no need to dispose the request and response manually, the plugin going to do it automatically after the callback.
2.) The plugin doesn't use Resources, so Resources.UnloadUnusedAssets(); has no effect.
3.) Cache and cookies doesn't use much memory, so you wouldn't gain too much disabling them either.
4.) You created a non-streaming request, the response Data is a byte[] containing the whole response. In this case, it contains 100 Mb of data.
5.) You are releasing the Data back to the plugin's memory pool. So even if you call GC.Collect a few lines down, you just added one another reference to that 100Mb of data making it impossible to the GC to reclaim.

So a few suggestions:

1.) If you don't want to download large contents, you can use streaming.
2.) You can disable MemoryPooling, but in the end you might end up with more garbage as the plugin can't reuse already allocated large chunks of memory. So instead of disabling it, i would suggest to lower the RemoveOlderThan's value.

 

Hi,
I have performed a speed test - downloaded file with size 248182482 bytes via BestHttp.
On Huawei pad this file was downloaded in 66 sec.

UseStreaming = true, streamFragmentSize = 64 * 1024

UnityWebRequest can download the same file on the same device in 28 sec.

So I tried to understand, why BestHttp is 2 times slower, than UWR.

In HTTPResponse class, in function ReadRaw, I measured
1. "Pure" time it takes for a socket to send bytes (Span1)
2. The time WaitWhileHasFragments function waits (Span2)

Stopwatch stopwatch1 = new Stopwatch();

Stopwatch stopwatch2 = new Stopwatch();

while (contentLength > 0)

{

   readBytes = 0;

   do

   {

       int readbuffer = (int)Math.Min(2147483646, (uint)contentLength);

       stopwatch1.Start();

       int bytes = stream.Read(buffer, readBytes, Math.Min(readbuffer, buffer.Length - readBytes));

       stopwatch1.Stop();

       if (bytes <= 0)

           throw ExceptionHelper.ServerClosedTCPStream();

       readBytes += bytes;

       contentLength -= bytes;

       // Progress report:

       baseRequest.Downloaded += bytes;

       baseRequest.DownloadProgressChanged = this.IsSuccess

#if !BESTHTTP_DISABLE_CACHING && (!UNITY_WEBGL || UNITY_EDITOR)

           || this.IsFromCache

#endif

           ;

   } while (readBytes < buffer.Length && contentLength > 0);

   if (baseRequest.UseStreaming)

   {

       // If reading from cache, we don't want to read too much data to memory. So we will wait until the loaded fragment processed.

       stopwatch2.Start();

       WaitWhileHasFragments();

       stopwatch2.Stop();

       if (gzipped)

       {

           var decompressed = Decompress(buffer, 0, readBytes);

           FeedStreamFragment(decompressed, 0, decompressed.Length);

       }

       else

           FeedStreamFragment(buffer, 0, readBytes);

   }

   else

       output.Write(buffer, 0, readBytes);

};

Debug.Log("Span1 = " + stopwatch1.Elapsed.TotalSeconds);

Debug.Log("Span2 = " + stopwatch2.Elapsed.TotalSeconds);   

Results:

2021-05-11 17:54:00.417 29568-29824/com.my.AddressablesTest I/Unity: Span1 = 42.2962665
2021-05-11 17:54:00.417 29568-29824/com.my.AddressablesTest I/Unity: Span2 = 22.8999408

It seemed suspiciously for me, that WaitWhileHasFragments is wasting 23 sec. But there is a comment:
// If reading from cache, we don't want to read too much data to memory. So we will wait until the loaded fragment processed.

WaitWhileHasFragments fuctions looks like this:

    void WaitWhileHasFragments()

{

#if !UNITY_WEBGL || UNITY_EDITOR

   while (baseRequest.UseStreaming &&

       #if !BESTHTTP_DISABLE_CACHING

           //this.IsFromCache &&

       #endif

       HasStreamedFragments())

   {

       #if NETFX_CORE

           await System.Threading.Tasks.Task.Delay(16);

       #else

           System.Threading.Thread.Sleep(16);

       #endif

   }

#endif

}

Why //this.IsFromCache is commented out? If we are not reading from cache, we don't have to wait.
So I changed this function like so:

    void WaitWhileHasFragments()

{

#if !BESTHTTP_DISABLE_CACHING && (!UNITY_WEBGL || UNITY_EDITOR)

   while (baseRequest.UseStreaming && this.IsFromCache && HasStreamedFragments())

   {

#if NETFX_CORE

       await System.Threading.Tasks.Task.Delay(16);

#else

       System.Threading.Thread.Sleep(16);

#endif

   }

#endif

}

And test file is downloading now in 42 sec.
BestHttp version is 1.10.3

What can you say about this?

 

@ArseniyMaryin

That you should try out Best HTTP/2. I made a lot of improvements to speed up upload and download speed.

 

I have using Best http 2.4.0 Latest plugin for Socket IO3 code

While using socket connection most of time I'm getting this error and also after socket IO3 joining the room unable to receive a event from server to unity.

{"tid":1,"div":"WebSocketTransport","msg":"OnBinary Packet parsing","ex": [{"msg": "Unexpected token readed 'BeginArray' while 'BeginObject' is expected.", "stack": " at GameDevWare.Serialization.Serializers.ObjectSerializer.Deserialize (GameDevWare.Serialization.IJsonReader reader) [0x00026] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Plugins\\GameDevWare.Serialization\\Serializers\\ObjectSerializer.cs:69 \r\n at GameDevWare.Serialization.JsonReaderExtentions.ReadValue (GameDevWare.Serialization.IJsonReader reader, System.Type valueType, System.Boolean nextToken) [0x00096] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Plugins\\GameDevWare.Serialization\\JsonReaderExtentions.cs:727 \r\n at BestHTTP.SocketIO3.Parsers.MsgPackParser.ReadParameters (BestHTTP.SocketIO3.Socket socket, BestHTTP.SocketIO3.Events.Subscription subscription, GameDevWare.Serialization.IJsonReader reader) [0x00098] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Examples\\SocketIO3\\Parsers\\MsgPackParser.cs:240 \r\n at BestHTTP.SocketIO3.Parsers.MsgPackParser.ReadData (BestHTTP.SocketIO3.SocketManager manager, BestHTTP.SocketIO3.IncomingPacket packet, GameDevWare.Serialization.IJsonReader reader) [0x000ee] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Examples\\SocketIO3\\Parsers\\MsgPackParser.cs:304 \r\n at BestHTTP.SocketIO3.Parsers.MsgPackParser.Parse (BestHTTP.SocketIO3.SocketManager manager, BestHTTP.PlatformSupport.Memory.BufferSegment data, BestHTTP.SocketIO3.TransportEventTypes transportEvent) [0x0010e] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Examples\\SocketIO3\\Parsers\\MsgPackParser.cs:146 \r\n at BestHTTP.SocketIO3.Transports.WebSocketTransport.OnBinary (BestHTTP.WebSocket.WebSocket ws, System.Byte[] data) [0x00053] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Source\\SocketIO.3\\Transports\\WebSocketTransport.cs:172 "}],"stack":" at SocketIO3.Transports.WebSocketTransport.OnBinary (WebSocket.WebSocket ws, System.Byte[] data) [0x0007a] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Source\\SocketIO.3\\Transports\\WebSocketTransport.cs:176 \r at WebSocket.WebSocket.<OnInternalRequestUpgraded>b__47_1 (WebSocket.WebSocketResponse ws, System.Byte[] bin) [0x0000e] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Source\\WebSocket\\WebSocket.cs:439 \r at WebSocket.WebSocketResponse.Core.IProtocol.HandleEvents () [0x000f7] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Source\\WebSocket\\WebSocketResponse.cs:540 \r at Core.ProtocolEventHelper.ProcessQueue () [0x00087] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Source\\Core\\ProtocolEvents.cs:69 \r at HTTPManager.OnUpdate () [0x0000d] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Source\\HTTPManager.cs:416 \r at HTTPUpdateDelegator.Update () [0x00020] in D:\\Pictures\\mopub testing\\Assets\\Best HTTP\\Source\\HTTPUpdateDelegator.cs:171 ","ctxs":[{"TypeName": "SocketManager", "Hash": -392288000}],"t":637568698150178555,"ll":"Exception","bh":1}
UnityEngine.Debug:LogError(Object)
BestHTTP.Logger.UnityOutput:Write(Loglevels, String) (at Assets/Best HTTP/Source/Logger/UnityOutput.cs:22)
BestHTTP.Logger.ThreadedLogger:ThreadFunc() (at Assets/Best HTTP/Source/Logger/ThreadedLogger.cs:130)
BestHTTP.PlatformSupport.Threading.<>c__DisplayClass5_0:<RunLongLiving>b__0() (at Assets/Best HTTP/Source/PlatformSupport/Threading/ThreadedRunner.cs:94)
System.Threading.ThreadHelper:ThreadStart(Object)

 

@deiva Is your server using the socket.io-msgpack-parser?

 

Yes. We using message MsgPackParser

 

@deiva

Could you send a repro project (client + server)? Or at least related code fragments from the client and server.

 

@BestHTTP

I have attached unity and server code for Socket.

 

@deiva

Could you try out with v2.5.0 that released yesterday?

 

Currently we using V2.5.0. Still we facing the issue.
public static string UserAgent = "BestHTTP/2 v2.5.0";

 

@deiva

In this case could you narrow down what's message causing problems? I just tried out and it's working as expected.

This was my server:

Code (JavaScript):

1. var app = require('http').createServer();
2.  
3. const customParser = require('socket.io-msgpack-parser');
4.  
5. var io = require('socket.io')(app, {
6.     parser: customParser
7. });
8.  
9. io.listen(3000);
10.  
11. io.of("bt_multiplayer").on("connection", (socket) => {
12.     socket.on("get_lobbies", () => {
13.         const lobbies = {
14.             lobbies: [
15.                 {
16.                     id: "001",
17.                     is_enabled: true,
18.                     maintenance: false,
19.                     room_type: "custom",
20.                     overs: 123,
21.                     balls_per_over: 3,
22.                     max_players: 100,
23.                     min_players: 20,
24.                     waiting_time: 4,
25.                     bot_players: false
26.                 },
27.  
28.                 {
29.                     id: "002",
30.                     is_enabled: false,
31.                     maintenance: true,
32.                     room_type: "roomie",
33.                     overs: 321,
34.                     balls_per_over: 6,
35.                     max_players: 64,
36.                     min_players: 8,
37.                     waiting_time: 2,
38.                     bot_players: true
39.                 }
40.             ]
41.         };
42.  
43.         socket.emit("lobbies_list", lobbies);
44.     });
45.  
46.     let _countdown = 5;
47.     let wait_time = setInterval(() => {
48.         if (_countdown <= 0) {
49.             clearInterval(wait_time);
50.         } else {
51.             socket.emit("wait_time_countdown", { countdown: _countdown });
52.             _countdown--;
53.             console.log("Countdown: ", _countdown);
54.         }
55.     }, 1000);
56.  
57.     socket.on("disconnect", () => {
58.         clearInterval(wait_time);
59.     });
60. });

And client:

Code (CSharp):

1. Socket nsp;
2.  
3. public override void Do_Test()
4. {
5.     SocketOptions options = new SocketOptions();
6.     options.AutoConnect = false;
7.     options.Reconnection = true;
8.     options.Timeout = TimeSpan.FromSeconds(10.0f);
9.     options.QueryParamsOnlyForHandshake = false;
10.     ObservableDictionary<string, string> query = new ObservableDictionary<string, string>();
11.  
12.     query["token"] = "QWER-REWQ-ASDF-FDSA";
13.     options.AdditionalQueryParams = query;
14.  
15.     var Manager = new SocketManager(new Uri("http://localhost:3000"), options);
16.     Manager.Parser = new MsgPackParser();
17.     Manager.Open();
18.  
19.     nsp = Manager.GetSocket("/bt_multiplayer");
20.     nsp.On<ConnectResponse>("connect", OnConnected);
21.     nsp.On("disconnect", OnDisconnected);
22.     nsp.On<Lobbies>("lobbies_list", OnLobbiesList);
23.     nsp.On<WaitTimeCountdown>("wait_time_countdown", OnWaitTimeCountdown);
24. }
25.  
26. private void OnWaitTimeCountdown(WaitTimeCountdown obj)
27. {
28.     Debug.Log($"OnWaitTimeCountdown: {obj.countdown}");
29. }
30.  
31. private void OnLobbiesList(Lobbies l)
32. {
33.     Debug.Log($"LobbiesList: {l?.lobbies?.Length}");
34.  
35.     foreach (Lobby lob in l.lobbies)
36.     {
37.         Debug.LogError("Lobbies " + lob.id);
38.  
39.         nsp.Emit("find_room", l.lobbies[1].id);
40.     }
41. }
42.  
43. private void OnDisconnected()
44. {
45.     Debug.Log("Disconnected!");
46. }
47.  
48. private void OnConnected(ConnectResponse resp)
49. {
50.     Debug.Log($"Connected with sid: {resp.sid}");
51.  
52.     nsp.Emit("get_lobbies");
53. }

 

The only issue is we are unable to get the room events. Kindly check server code.


Client Code:

Code (CSharp):

1.  
2.  
3. void Start(){
4. nsp = Manager.GetSocket("/bt_multiplayer");
5. nsp.On<ConnectResponse>("connect", OnConnected);
6.  
7. nsp.On("direct_event", () => {
8. Debug.LogError("Event triggered Directly");
9. });
10.  
11. nsp.On("room_event", () => {                    
12. Debug.LogError("Event triggered from room");
13. });
14. }
15.  
16. private void OnConnected(ConnectResponse resp)
17. {
18. Debug.LogError("Connected");
19. nsp.Emit("join_room");
20. }

Server:

Code (JavaScript):

1. var app = require("http").createServer();
2.  
3. const customParser = require("socket.io-msgpack-parser");
4.  
5. var io = require("socket.io")(app, {
6.   parser: customParser,
7. });
8.  
9. io.listen(3000);
10.  
11. io.of("bt_multiplayer").on("connection", (socket) => {
12.   console.log("Connected");
13.   socket.on("join_room", () => {
14.     console.log("Join Room");
15.     socket.emit("direct_event");
16.  
17.     socket.join("ROOM_12345");
18.     io.to("ROOM_12345").emit("room_event");
19.   });
20. });

 

@deiva

The client connects, sends the "join_room" event, receives "direct_event", but the server doesn't sent the "room_event":

 

Used DEBUG=* environment variable for the server log

 

@deiva What's strange is though that the server (socket.io v4.1.2 on my end) sends binary and text websocket messages, however data sent msgpack encoded should sent binary only.
Your errors are orignate from binary messages to make it more confusing...

 

@deiva I might found one or two issues in socket.io, going to continue investigate and if i'm right report them.

 

@BestHTTP
You are right. We found some issues in Socket IO v4.1.2 and V4.1.1.
We posted in https://github.com/socketio/socket.io/issues/3935 - Unable to emit or trigger an event to a room id.

 

@deiva Added some details to the issue.

 

@BestHTTP
Hello. I have a question related to the issue that I created - https://github.com/Benedicht/BestHTTP-Issues/issues/60

I'm using HTTPRequest.ProcessingStarted to determine request execution time and correct my local time to the server time.

Code (CSharp):

1. var req = new HTTPRequest(uri, HTTPMethods.Get);
2. req.Callback += (request, response) =>
3. {
4.     TimeSpan requestExecutionTime = DateTime.UtcNow - request.ProcessingStarted;
5. };
6. req.Send();

I read about Timing API and now a bit confused about my implementation. Is it more accurate and correct to retrieve request execution time, like this way? Assuming that I'm not using caching.

Code (CSharp):

1. var req = new HTTPRequest(uri, HTTPMethods.Get);
2. req.Callback += (request, response) =>
3. {
4.     var firstTiming = request.Timing.FindFirst(TimingEventNames.Request_Sent);
5.     var lastTiming = request.Timing.FindLast(TimingEventNames.Response_Received);
6.  
7.     TimeSpan requestExecutionTime = lastTiming.When - firstTiming.When;
8. };
9. req.Send();

 

@wicea I would recommend to use the Timing API, it can give a more realistic view about the timing as it going to include redirects too.

 

HTTPUpdateDelegator.Update takes quite some time, any idea how can we get around this?

 

@umityayla

Those high times are most probably from the callbacks added for HTTPRequests. HTTPUpdateDelegator.Update is where the callbacks are called from.

Mono.JIT: Contains samples that relate to just-in-time compilation of a scripting method. When a function is executed for the first time, Mono compiles it and Mono.JIT represents this compilation overhead.
(https://docs.unity3d.com/Manual/profiler-markers.html)

 

Hi, some remarks about the latest BestHttp 2.5.0:

1. Debug stack trace collection in BufferPool.cs needs to be switched off. BestHttp is extremely slow in Editor otherwise.
2. It seems that SendBufferSize and ReceiveBufferSize are not optimal at least for one device - Huawei MediaPad M3.

On my Internet, BestHttp 2.5.0 can download a 250 MB file in 45 seconds, but if I comment these strings:

Client.SendBufferSize = HTTPManager.SendBufferSize;
Client.ReceiveBufferSize = HTTPManager.ReceiveBufferSize;

the same file can be downloaded in 28 seconds.

 

@ArseniyMaryin

1.) It's fixed in the next release i plan to do this week.
2.) I'm going to try to investigate it, thanks.

 

Just wanted to chime in and say that I've been using BestHTTP for years now for websockets to custom built servers hosted through mono on linux via AWS EC2s.

My infrastructure was complicated migrating away from back-end services to custom and the headaches behind it were nasty, but being able to facilitate quick integration with websockets (instead of regular tcp sockets through flash back in the day) was a godsend.

At any given moment there's thousands of players live on the game with stable connections and I have no instabilities caused by using BestHTTP that I'm aware of.

Unity has been a nightmare with its engine bugs, and every other service/library has been underwhelming except this one from my experience.

So in any case, I just wanted to say...thanks! Best asset on the store by far, and I only use the bare minimum basics of it. I can't believe how awesome and far the features for it stretch.

 

Thanks @IOU_RAY, i'm really happy that you have a great experience with the plugin! Can ask you o post this as a review in the asset store too? That would be really helpful, i'm sure the plugin's review page is a better place for those who want to decide to by the plugin. Anyhow, i'm glad you wrote it down and last but not least, what's the game? I'm really enjoying trying out games using the plugin.

 

Hehe, I did 4 years ago already! Just wanted to bombard further with compliments this much time after



Cheers.

 

Hi,
We are using Best HTTP Plugin version 2.3.2 and Unity Editor version 2019.4.16f1 for our project. Upon using the SDK we are facing an issue in which Get methods are sent from client side(Unity), but not reaching the server side. But, we are receiving the response as empty in client side(Unity). Please note that this happens rarely. Kindly help us to resolve this issue.

 

@Shankar-Ganesh

Unfortunately, without detailed logs i can't say too much. What do you mean when you write that "the response as empty in client side"? Is the response object null? Or the response object isn't null, but the Data (or DataAsText) property empty?
Do you do any error handling?

 

Hi,

It went into HTTPRequestsStates.Error case and response object is not null. statusCode is 0 and DataAsText became as empty.

 

@Shankar-Ganesh Yes, in case of Error state the response object going to be null. What would be good to know is what's the exception (its message and stack trace).
What would be even better is if you could capture a full log (HTTPManager.Logger.Level = Logger.Loglevels.All;) and send it over to me.

 

@BestHTTP

Hi.
I get warning message ,when I abort request.
[Failed to read Status Line! Retry is disabled, re-throwing exception]
Is this normal?
If I abort request after get reponse.No warning message show.

Code (CSharp):

1.     private HTTPRequest _request;
2.     public void RequestStart(string url)
3.     {
4.         _request = new HTTPRequest(new Uri(url), (req, res) =>
5.         {
6.  
7.         });
8.         _request.Send();
9.     }
10.  
11.     public void Abort()
12.     {
13.         _request.Abort();
14.     }
15.     void Update()
16.     {
17.         if (Input.GetKeyDown(KeyCode.A))
18.         {
19.             RequestStart("http://localhost/test.php"); //takes long time to response
20.         }
21.         if (Input.GetKeyDown(KeyCode.B))
22.         {
23.             Abort();
24.         }  
25.     }

 

@xharkx You can ignore this warning, i'm going to fix it in the next release.

 

Ok Thank you.

 

How do I save the downloaded data in the Response object to a local file?

For example:
if (resp.IsSuccess)
{
var filePath = "/local/file/path/image.jpg"
// Save resp.Data to filePath here
}

I can't find anything about this in the docs. Thanks!

 

@lumeneo You can do something like this:

Code (CSharp):

1. System.IO.File.WriteAllBytes("/local/file/path/to/image.jpg", resp.Data);

 

@BestHTTP will this plugin works seamless over websocket communication even if incoming message json from server is big?? do we have any setting that can enable big message reading??

 

@sandeepsmartest How big? The plugin implements writing and reading fragmented frames, but the final data must be less then 2^32 (2 GiB).

Edit: What I would suggtest is to make sure your server supports Per-Message Compression, for large json messages i'm sure you could save a lot on bandwidth with it.

 

Hello, BestHTTP team!
How can I simulate that logic written with .net HttpClient with your HttpRequest?

Code (CSharp):

1.  
2. using (var client = new HttpClient())
3. {
4.     using (var stream = await client.GetStreamAsync(new Uri(url)))
5.     {
6.         //save data from stream to disk
7.     }
8. }
9.  

And one more question. Does BestHttp work in background thread? Can't it lead to spikes in main unity thread? Because I get app crash quite often related threads. It might happens due to creating requests in another thread

Thanks!

 

@Serhii-Horun

You can use streaming: https://benedicht.github.io/BestHTTP-Documentation/#1.HTTP/AdvancedTopics/DownloadStreaming/

The plugin uses (background)threads to upload and download the requests, but callbacks are dispatched on unity's main threads. Code placed in the callbacks can cause cpu spikes.

 

Hi again!

We have one more question. Do we need to dispose requests and response by ourself?

Code (CSharp):

1. using (var request = new HTTPRequest(new Uri("some_address")))
2. {
3.       using (var response = await request.GetHTTPResponseAsync())
4.       {
5.                  
6.       }
7. }

Or it will be enough just to do like that(without "using" keyword):

Code (CSharp):

1. var request = new HTTPRequest(new Uri("some_address"));
2. var response = await request.GetHTTPResponseAsync();

Thanks!

 

@Serhii-Horun Dispose is called automatically by the plugin on them, no need to do it manually.

 

I'm testing this PlayFab Messaging Sample with Best HTTP/2:
https://github.com/PlayFab/PlayFab-Samples/tree/master/Samples/CSharp/MessagingClient

It works beautifully except for a small hack: Because the PlayFab server function GetSignalRConnection can return SignalR uri & accessToken in its result SignalRConnectionInfo class:

I can set up the HubConnection.NegotiationResult.AccessToken directly like this:

Code (CSharp):

1.  
2. var hubConnection = new HubConnection(new Uri(mySignalRConnectionInfo.uri), protocol);
3.  
4. hubConnection.NegotiationResult = new NegotiationResult();
5. hubConnection.NegotiationResult.AccessToken = mySignalRConnectionInfo.accessToken;
6.  

Both NegotiationResult and NegotiationResult.AccessToken are private properties. So I need to tweak the code to make it works:

Code (CSharp):

1.  
2. // public NegotiationResult NegotiationResult { get; private set; }
3. public NegotiationResult NegotiationResult { get; set; }
4.  
5. // public string AccessToken { get; private set; }
6. public string AccessToken { get; set; }
7.  

Is there any alternative way to do the same thing without modifying their accessibility levels?

BTW, this is for an Unity client to serverlessly connect to a SignalR Service hub without requiring an ASP.NET Core backend by using package Microsoft.Azure.WebJobs.Extensions.SignalRService

 

@mobilEKG You can implement a new authenticator where you can pass the received accesstoken to its constructor. (A better implementation would be one that gets the connection info and its accessToken itself, encapsulating the authentication process.)

 

Hi, I love the asset and its features so far but I ran into one minor issue... The SecureProtocol folder contains about 3000 files from the BouncyCastle APIs. Is it possible to use their DLL instead to avoid having so much bulk here? It's not too big a problem, and I appreciate having access to the source just in case, but I was just wondering if there was a tidier alternative.

Thanks!

 

@PW_Avi No, the dll version of BC wouldn't work. I had to modify and add features to increase its performance and be usable for HTTP/2.

 

@BestHTTP - Hi there, I'm having issues getting proxy credentials working for HTTP calls.

Code (CSharp):

1. Credentials credentials = new Credentials("user", "password");
2.  
3. request.Proxy = new HTTPProxy(new Uri("http://proxyIP:proxyPort"), credentials,false, false);

If I use a proxy that doesn't require user/pass authentication I can get it to work, but every time I try with one of my proxies that requires a user/pass it times out.

Any help would be appreciated, thanks.

 

@HolyFireGames

What proxy are you using? You can set the plugin's logging to verbose and send the produced logs to me: https://benedicht.github.io/BestHTTP-Documentation/#7.GlobalTopics/Logging/