Anti aliasing not working in unity3d 2017.1.0f1

Anti aliasing not working in unity3d 2017.1.0f1, Chrome, Firefox and Edge ...

Building the same project ... with unity3D 5.6.1f1 work fine ...

but with unity3d 2017.1.0f1 anti aliasing fail

* Rendering path Forward ...

Regards ...

 

Hi again ...

Importing the project directly (unity conversion) anti aliasing does not work ...

... but i try creating new project empty, copying files & manually resetting options ... & now work fine, ok

 

Hi again ...


After many tests ...

... forcing graphics to api webgl 1.0, anti aliasing work fine in versions 5.5.4p1 or lower ... but no work in 5.6.2p1 or 2017.1.0f1

Concreting: I like use webgl 1.0 because it improves performance of certain things but in versions highers at 5.5 no work anti aliasing ... Chrome, Firefox and Edge ...

¿Any solution? Thanks, regards ...

* forcing to api webgl 2.0 work fine always, only fail forcing to webgl 1.0

 

Hi Marco !

Thank you, i did not know that ... but no, it is not the case, no use Image Effects ...

... it's more, it works fine in versions 5.5.4p1 or lower ...

Regards ...

 

Check with unity 5.6 or highter ... new project, create only 1 sphere, activate anti aliasing in options and force api to webgl1.0 ... you can see that anti aliasing work in editor but stops working in browsers

 

@Marco-Trivellato
I post a bug (Case 951565).
WebGL AA is disabled after button click.
no image effects.
but also I think it's webGL 2.0
on unity 5.5 same button click does not disable AA, it's related to updates in 5.6

also may be it's related to browser bugs and api, in old chrome AA is work on 5.6 on my machine, but not on other people's

p.s.
which exactly conditional "if" disables AA on web? it's in unity code or in browser? may be it's false positive due to renderTexture or custom shader?

 

I post a bug 951565 with Version 5.6.3p2_b3d7a6428558, it's not fixed in my case

 

hello! I can't attach the project from video - it's huge closed codebase, not test project,
but I have tested some cases, and created new bug report (Case 953509)
with simple scene in unity 5.6.2f1 and 5.6.3p3 - AA is totally not work for me, but work in 5.5..
in old (full) project AA is work prior to button click and disables after click.. all my simple tries for cut the full project for pieces not reproduces "AA work prior to click" and lead to totally AA disablied - finally I have attached only simple project, but in all sequent tries AA is not work at all in 5.6

p.s. I must mention - AA not work in firefox 55.0.3 (32 bit) (local build, and build downloaded from my server) but work in chrome (from server) (screen from chrome http://prntscr.com/gotzyg)
more precisely: AA is not work in unity 5.6.2f1 and 5.6.3p3 when build tested in firefox 55.0.3 (latest), but AA work in firefox when build is builded in unity 5.5;
AA is work in chrome 60.0.3112.113 (64 bit) builded on both 5.5 and 5.6
also it's tested not only on my machine, but in my collegue too.

 

I have found a reason - it's HDR:
0) people from support help me with test project, where WebGL 1.0 in firefox (latest) disables MSAA when HDR on main camera is turned on.

but other reasons match too:
1) after convertion 5.5 to 5.6 project - all scene cameras turns on his HDR.
2) on dynamic created cameras (I use SVG Importer plugin, and it uses this feature, but it's not image effect) new camera makes HDR enabled.

webgl 2.0 not have this issue. but why 2.0 is disables by default in latest browsers?

unity 5.5. is ok with it due to disabled HDR.

also I have read "Graphics: Added HDR MSAA anti-aliasing support. HDR rendering and MSAA anti-aliasing now works as expected with forward shading." in unity 5.6 news, it not true for webGL 1.0

 

p.s. in my video from case 951565 - runtime created camera with default HDR enabled disables MSAA.

 

Thanks, in my case it works.